There have been large battles over this, mostly with Walrus leading the pro side and tim leading the side against. So here is where the final bout will be held. Is Fullmetal Alchemist the worst anime?

Rules:
- No random "it sucks, no reason needed" bullshit. Give valid reasons.
- No mod powers (editing, deleting)
- No spam
- Don't wane sides, pick a side and stick to it.


Obviously, as you know, I love FMA. At first I thought it was bad because of the huge fanbase for Ed, and the fact that one of the main characters is a suit of armor. It looked like a stupid concept. But after several people told me to watch, I did.

I really think its a great anime, but not the greatest. There are a few minor problems and the ending right out sucked, but I still stand by the fact that it isn't the worst anime ever.